The Ten Crore Donkeys That Are The Masses

A wonderful song, based on a Habib Jalib poem, by the Pakistani group Laal. (Via)

Pankaj Mishra also points out some plain truths (hello, Fareed Zakaria!) in a piece in the Guardian. (Via)

And Sourabh sends me these links (here and here) to sites that present the lives of Indian workers in Special Exploitation Zone.

Jewish Writing is Over

Jewish-Americans did something in American literature that no other culture has done— they created world-class literature out of the immigrant experience. And that’s the only thing that mattered in Jewish-American writing. Had Roth and Bellow not been major talents, you wouldn’t have Jewish-American writing. It wouldn’t mean anything. It would just be parochial, local.

But we cannot have major talent writing this stuff anymore because there’s nothing to write about. What made them major was their gripe, the chip on their shoulders. The rage that they felt at the world for keeping them out. That experience became a great metaphor. There is no hyphenated Jewish experience anymore. I have two nieces who are both Ivy League babies and they’re in the ruling class. There’s nothing they can’t do. Nothing.

So there’s nothing to talk about. There’s really nothing to write about. Yet you have young people who keep on doing it. All I’m saying is, it doesn’t count. Take Michael Chabon, or Jonathan Safran Foer. They’re cashing in on a world that’s long gone and they’re writing with open nostalgia. They’re making things out of it that belong to their grandfathers. It’s a habit to go on assuming that this is legitimate writing. But I truly feel it is not.

Vivian Gornick in the Boston Review.

vivian-gornick-boston-review-interview